Critique conflicts
Tuesday, October 16, 2007
Even though my Inner Critic is now touring Provence, I still find myself surrounded by criticism. That's because I finally received the critiques from one of the contests I entered this summer. ;)
It's all good; I'm still breathing. Constructive feedback is a gift. Now that gift rage exists (see my post from yesterday), I will take a moment to thank any and every judge who filled out a scoresheet for H&B. :::pauses a moment for effect:::
All I meant to do was print out the scoresheets so that I'd be able to review them at a later date. Seriously. It was just a spooky coincidence that I grabbed the warm pages from the printer and proceeded to read them before the ink was barely dry. ;)
Where everyone has the same opinion, I'm cool. In fact, most of those things I've already revised in the fourth or sixty-sixth draft. ;)
Thank goodness I took out the cast of thousands and all those restaurant scenes like my lovely betas suggested...no, demanded.
Then there are the yins and yangs of counsel and concern. The wangs and the chungs. One hates this while the other wants more of it. Some LOL while others don't get the punchline. Each comment brings about an over-the-top reaction like those from Sally Field ("You really like me!") to Greta Garbo ("I vant to be alone").
I'm tempted to keep score. There's no need to though, because they already did. Le sigh.
And the best part of all?
I can use all of this to make the novel even better. Just not today. Or even this month.
It's all good; I'm still breathing. Constructive feedback is a gift. Now that gift rage exists (see my post from yesterday), I will take a moment to thank any and every judge who filled out a scoresheet for H&B. :::pauses a moment for effect:::
All I meant to do was print out the scoresheets so that I'd be able to review them at a later date. Seriously. It was just a spooky coincidence that I grabbed the warm pages from the printer and proceeded to read them before the ink was barely dry. ;)
Where everyone has the same opinion, I'm cool. In fact, most of those things I've already revised in the fourth or sixty-sixth draft. ;)
Thank goodness I took out the cast of thousands and all those restaurant scenes like my lovely betas suggested...no, demanded.
Then there are the yins and yangs of counsel and concern. The wangs and the chungs. One hates this while the other wants more of it. Some LOL while others don't get the punchline. Each comment brings about an over-the-top reaction like those from Sally Field ("You really like me!") to Greta Garbo ("I vant to be alone").
I'm tempted to keep score. There's no need to though, because they already did. Le sigh.
And the best part of all?
I can use all of this to make the novel even better. Just not today. Or even this month.
Labels: writing
posted by Bonnie Staring at 8:00 AM
7 Comments:
The wangs and the chungs. *snort*
Everybody wang chung tonight.
Seriously, I know its hard. I do.
So I think we should sing Wang Chung in Frisco at the Karaoke bar. I read my Lonely Planet guide to Frisco, the only decent Karaoke bar is in the Castro district, yes, think Wellsley Street in Toronto and you have the Castro district.
I'm there to sing Wang Chung if you are.
Michelle, I heard you all the way over here. ;)
Amy, that offer terrifies me and excites me at the same time...do we all have to dress up as Cher? LOL
Cher? No, but I'll do the girls from ABBA!
Sorry I'll dress up as the girls from ABBA I don't swing that way.
LOL on the Wangs and Chungs.
And IMO, if you're getting conflicting advice, it means you've got something good. If it sucked, everyone would just be telling you so. :-)
Sifting through conflicting advice is tough. Go with your gut.
Oh Maureen, I went with my gut tonight and ended up at Dairy Queen instead of the computer. ;(
It's interesting that with novel writing conflict is what I need to aim for while in with copywriting it's what I need to avoid.
Wang Chung, however, works either way.
Okay Amy, there'll be no swinging in San Fran...but you do have to dress up as BOTH of the ABBA girls! A la Victor/Victoria.
Can't wait to see it! LMAO
Post a Comment
<< Home